THE 2004 BOUVIER HEALTH SURVEY

 

 

 

 

Presented by Margaret Slater, DVM,PhD

With help from Brenda L. Jacklitsch

Released August 30, 2005

 

Sponsored by

The BOUVIER HEALTH FOUNDATION

 

The Survey and other Bouvier Health Foundation Projects are made possible by the commitment of the membership of the ABdFC. The membership of the ABdFC actively commits time to these projects and participates generously in funding the projects. Congratulations to all who made this Survey possible and to all Bouvier lovers who participated in the Survey.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Background

The Bouvier Health Foundation requested a general health survey for bouviers whose owners belong to the American Bouvier des Flandres Club. The purpose was to find possible emerging breed-related health problems, so that concerns and breed problems can be addressed. Previous surveys were used as a basis for the current survey.

Methods

The survey was mailed to all members of the American Bouvier des Flandres Club on October 18, 2005. Names were added to the list of members being mailed surveys. These additional names were given ID numbers that could be distinguished from the original names for the purpose of calculating response rates. Postcard reminders were sent out on December 8, 2004 encouraging owners to return the survey even if it was blank because they no longer owned bouviers. Non-responders were called beginning in April 2005. New copies of the surveys were mailed out to non-responders in June 2005.

Answers from the surveys were compiled into excel spreadsheets under each survey identification number. Then data was sorted into tables for easier analysis. In most cases, variables (i.e. age, sex) were specifically noted in the tables. It should be made clear that ages are in years, except when noted.

When results showed more than a 2% difference between male and female dogs in any particular health category, then a chi-square test was used to analyze the data. Two percent was chosen as a large enough difference to be biologically or clinically important. If the resulting p-value was less than or equal to 0.05, then it was considered statistically significant. Having a statistically significant p-value indicates a difference between the sexes and the frequency of these health problems.

Results

There were a total of 1057 bouvier owners and members of the club who responded with information that could be used for the survey results. Originally, 1582 members were sent surveys and as names were added to the mailing list, an additional 79 surveys were mailed. However, 112 of these were bad addresses, and were not counted. Eleven blank forms were returned, 25 surveys were returned specifying they no longer had bouviers, and there were two unusable returned surveys. Overall, we had a 71% response rate which is moderately high. Information about the response rate can be found in Table A-1. The two returned surveys that were not usable had been answered in an uninterpretable manner, such as, having multiple dogs but not specifying the number of dogs afflicted by an illness and instead simply checking items off. Possible reasons as to why the rest did not reply cannot be certain. Reasons could include: 1) too time consuming; 2) too many dogs to include; 3) too many health problems; 4) very few or no health problems; 5) have not recently owned Bouviers; 6) some other unknown reason. The higher the response rate, the more accurate and conclusive the data. The survey includes a total of 3450 Bouviers. The top ten most reported health problems were cancer, stillbirths, sebaceous cysts, hot spots, arthritis, hip dysplasia, hypothyroidism, food allergies, fading puppies, and dermatitis. An overall plot of the health problems surveyed can be found in Graph A-1 in Appendix I.

 

The first page of the survey was general information about the Bouvier owners and their dogs. The median number of years an individual had owned bouviers was 12.5 years. Most owners currently only had one dog; the maximum number of dogs a person owned was twenty. General information can be found in Table A-2. The most popular activities that these bouviers participated in are pet companion, conformation, and obedience (Table A-3). See also Graph A-2. Owners reported to be most concerned with cancer, hip dysplasia, and heart problems, as seen in Table A-4. This can also be seen in Graph A-3.

There are 2410 living bouviers and 1040 deceased bouviers, for a total of 3450 dogs included in this survey. The average age of living dogs are 5.5 years for males and 6 years for females. The average age at time of death was 10 years for males and 10.5 years for females. The oldest age achieved before death was reported to be 19.5 years for a male and 18 years for a female. Information regarding the age of dogs can be found in Table A-5. The most common causes of death included cancer, old age, heart failure, accidental, and bloat. Old age is a general term; however an exact cause of death was not noted. Table A-6 has a complete list of causes of death.

Differences between the sexes were found in eight health problems using our 2% rule and chi-square calculations. Males were more likely to have hot spots and hip dysplasia. Females were more likely to have mammary carcinomas, sebaceous cysts, missing teeth, bladder infections, incontinence, and incontinence from neutering.

Cancer was one of the most reported health problems. See Table B-1. The identified cancers most often reported were lymphoma, mast cell lymphosarcoma, osteosarcoma, and mammary carcinoma. The top 15 most reported cancers can be seen in Graph B-1. Nineteen percent of the dogs included in the survey had been diagnosed with some form of cancer. There was a significant difference between the sexes reported with mammary cancer. Not surprisingly, female bouviers were 41 times more likely to be diagnosed with mammary carcinoma than males.

Non malignant tumors and cysts (Table B-2) were reported in nineteen percent of the bouviers. Females were 1.3 times more likely to have sebaceous cysts. Skin and hair problems (Table B-3) affected approximately twenty-six percent of the dogs. Sixteen percent had hot spots. Females were 1.3 times more likely to have hot spots than males.

Eye problems affected approximately eleven percent of the dogs surveyed as can be seen in Table B-4. Almost four percent were affected by cataracts. It should be noted that some people were confused of whether their dog had primary or secondary glaucoma. There were also relatively few dogs in each glaucoma group, so age trends cannot be determined. Ten percent of the dogs were reported to have ear problems (Table B-5). The most common ear problems were inner ear infections (4.6%) and chronic external ear infections (3.5%). Problems with the mouth and teeth affected eleven percent of the bouviers (Table B-6). Four percent had missing teeth. Females were almost 2 times more likely to have teeth missing.

Drug reactions occurred in almost five percent of the dogs, as seen in Table B-7. Reactions to anesthesia were the most reported, affecting 1.7% of the population surveyed. Respiratory problems affected less than one percent of bouviers surveyed (Table B-8).

More than twelve percent of the dogs reported autoimmune or immune problems (Table B-9). Almost seven percent had food allergies. The top food allergies noted were beef, corn, and wheat. Graph B-2 shows the top ten food allergies. Inhaled allergies affected almost four percent of the dogs. One percent of the dogs suffered from rheumatoid arthritis.

Endocrine problems, like those listed in Table B-10, affected more than nine percent of the bouviers. Hypothyroidism affected 6.7% of the dogs. Problems with muscles (Table B-11), such as, myopathy and myasthenia gravis affected less than half of a percent.

Twenty-eight percent of the dogs had bone and skeletal problems, as seen in Table B-12. Arthritis affected eleven percent and hip dysplasia affected eight percent. Males were 1.5 times more likely to have hip dysplasia than females. See Graph B-3 to view skeletal problems.

Gastrointestinal tract problems occurred in twelve percent of the bouviers (Table B-13). Impacted anal glands affected 2.6% of the total dogs. Stomach bloat occurred in 1.9%. Liver and spleen problems were noted in one percent of the survey population (Table B-14).

Urinary tract problems affected 12.6% of the total dogs. See Table B-15. More than five percent of the females had experienced at least one bladder infection. Females were 3.9 times more likely to have had a bladder infection than males. Incontinence and incontinence from neutering was 4.0 times and 5.4 times more likely to occur in females than males.

Almost eight percent of the bouviers had experienced a heart problem, as can be seen in Table B-16. Congestive heart failure occurred in 2.2% of the dogs and subvalvular aortic Stenosis (SAS) occurred in 1.3% of the dogs. Seventeen heart murmur grades were recorded; the median grade was 1.7. Heart murmur grades were recorded in cases of SAS, DCM, mitral valve murmurs, PDA, tricuspid valve dysplasia, and murmurs from illness. If a cause was not included with a grade, then it was grouped as an unspecified murmur. Heart problems can be found in Graph B-4. Neurological problems affected 3.7% of the total number of dogs (Table B-17). One and a half percent had experienced a single seizure, and almost one percent had epilepsy.

Reproductive problems occurred more often in females than males. Almost twenty percent of the female dogs were affected, while only six and a half percent of the males were affected. The most common problems in females were pyometras (5.0%), cesarean births (4.9%), and abnormal heat cycles (4.2%); as can be seen in Table C-2. The most common problems in males were mono/cryptorchidism (1.6%) and benign prostatic hyperplasia (1.4%), as seen in Table C-3. Almost twenty-five percent of the total dogs were bred at least once (Table C-1). In the past six years, 702 litters were reported (Table C-4). Litter and puppy problems occurred in 33.5% of the litters, as seen in Table C-5. Stillborn puppies occurred in 17.4% of the litters; and fading puppies occurred in 6.6% of the litters.

Discussion

The response rate was approximately 71%, which was a moderately high rate. Problems encountered included some respondents were unfamiliar with medical terms, some found the instructions confusing, and some checked off conditions but did not specify the number of dogs affected. Cancer was the health problem that owners were most concerned about; and cancer was the number one cause of death in bouviers surveyed. Differences between the sexes of more than 2% were found in eight health problems. Males were more likely to have hot spots and hip dysplasia. Females were more likely to have mammary carcinomas, sebaceous cysts, missing teeth, bladder infections, incontinence, and incontinence from neutering. From this survey of 3450 bouviers, the top ten most reported health problems were cancer, stillbirths, sebaceous cysts, hot spots, arthritis, hip dysplasia, hypothyroidism, food allergies, fading puppies, and dermatitis.

 

Table A-1: Response Rate Information

 

 

Table A-2: General Info On Dogs

 

 

 

 

 

 

Table A-3: Owner Activities

 

 

Table A-4: Owner Health Concerns

 

Table A-5: Dog Ages

 

 

Table A-6: Causes of Death

Table B-1: Cancer

 

 

 

 

Table B-2: Nonmalignant Tumors & Cysts

 

 

Table B-3: Skin & Hair Problems

 

 

Table B-4: Eye Problems

 

 

Table B-5: Ear Problems

 

 

 

 

Table B-6: Mouth Problems

 

 

Table B-7: Drug Reactions

 

 

Table B-8: Respiratory Problems

 

Table B-9: Autoimmune & Immune System Problems

 

 

Table B-10: Endocrine System Problems

 

Table B-11: Muscle Problems

 

 

Table B-12: Skeletal Problems

 

 

Table B-13: Gastrointestinal Tract Problems

 

 

Table B-14: Liver & Spleen Problems

 

 

Table B-15: Urinary Tract Problems

 

 

Table B-16: Heart Problems

 

 

Table B-17: Neurological Problems

 

 

 

 

Table C-1: Bouviers Bred

 

 

Table C-2: Female Reproductive Problems

 

 

Table C-3: Male Reproductive Problems

 

 

 

Table C-4: Litters

 

 

Table C-5: Litter & Puppy Problems

 

Appendix I: Graphs

Graph A-1: Health Problems

Graph A-2: Owner Activities

 

Graph A-3: Owner Concerns

Graph B-1: Top 15 Cancers in Bouviers

 

Graph B-2: Top Food Allergies

Graph B-3: Skeletal Problems

Graph B-4: Heart Problems

Appendix II: Incoming Surveys Plot

 

 

Appendix III: 2 x 2 Tables

 

Mammary Carcinoma

 

Sebaceous Cysts

 

+

-

Total

 

 

+

-

Total

Female

55

1931

1986

 

Female

346

1640

1986

Male

1

1463

1464

 

Male

196

1268

1464

Total

56

3394

3450

 

Total

542

2908

3450

RR

40.54

CI

(5.62,292.65)

 

RR

1.3

CI

(1.11,1.53)

Chi-Sq

38.5

P-value

< 0.0001

 

Chi-Sq

10.36

P-value

0.00129

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Hot Spots

 

Missing Teeth

 

+

-

Total

 

 

+

-

Total

Male

267

1197

1464

 

Female

100

1886

1986

Female

274

1712

1986

 

Male

39

1425

1464

Total

541

2909

3450

 

Total

139

3311

3450

RR

1.32

CI

(1.13,1.54)

 

RR

1.89

CI

(1.31,2.72)

Chi-Sq

12.57

P-value

0.000392

 

Chi-Sq

12.26

P-value

0.0004638

 

 

 

 

 

 

Hip Dysplasia

Bladder Infection

 

+

-

Total

 

+

-

Total

Male

146

1318

1464

Female

107

1879

1986

Female

135

1851

1986

Male

20

1444

1464

Total

281

3169

3450

Total

127

3323

3450

RR

1.47

CI

(1.17,1.84)

RR

3.94

CI

(2.46,6.33)

Chi-Sq

11.36

P-value

0.000752

Chi-Sq

38.44

P-value

< 0.0001

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Incontinence

 

Incontinence from Neutering

 

+

-

Total

 

 

+

-

Total

Female

60

1926

1986

 

Female

80

1906

1986

Male

11

1453

1464

 

Male

11

1453

1464

Total

71

3379

3450

 

Total

91

3359

3450

RR

4.02

CI

(2.12,7.62)

 

RR

5.36

CI

(2.86,10.03)

Chi-Sq

21.54

P-value

0.0000035

 

Chi-Sq

35.24

P-value

< 0.0001